Teaching Wittgenstein’s Investigations Through Creative Writing
Ordinary language philosophy examines how words acquire meaning in use, while literary studies attends to how language builds scenes, voices and possible worlds. Wittgenstein’s Philosophical Investigations bridges the two traditions. Its discussions of language-games, rule-following, forms of life and private language invite questions that can be tested through composition rather than answered by doctrinal summary.
Teaching Wittgenstein’s Philosophical Investigations in a creative writing class lets students read a passage as an event in language: who is speaking, to whom, under what conventions, and what would change if the setting changed. The method preserves philosophical difficulty while giving it material consequences. A tram announcement, job interview or grieving letter can show how rules, expectations and contexts shape sense.
Australian classrooms bring local habits into this inquiry. In Melbourne, Sydney, Brisbane and Adelaide, students may move between campus, suburban libraries and neighbourhood cafés between seminars and writing workshops; trams, ferries and buses also provide public settings for observing speech. Readings in Melbourne, state library e-lending services and second-hand bookshops make editions accessible. Classroom reproduction of texts should follow the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) and any applicable education provisions.
The aim is not to turn creative writing into a disguised philosophy tutorial. It is to make ordinary language visible as a practice that writers enter, inherit and alter. A strong unit combines short philosophical readings, bounded writing experiments, peer discussion and reflective commentary on revision.
Begin with Language in Use
Philosophical Investigations resists a tidy linear route. Rather than begin with a history of the book or a master concept, introduce its characteristic question: what are we doing when we use this word here? Start with an ordinary phrase such as “You’re right,” then vary the speaker, listener and stakes. Students discover that no paraphrase captures every use and that context is not a decorative addition to language.
Pair this exercise with a short scene. Require three versions in which the same sentence accepts, challenges, consoles or ends a conversation. In discussion, name the relevant language-game and form of life without treating either as a code with one official interpretation. Moving from speech to writing shows that rules operate through practice.
Language-Games, Places and Social Action
A language-game is a practical activity into which words enter, such as naming, bargaining, apologising, teaching or joking. Its rules are learned through examples and participation. Literary scenes are therefore ideal laboratories: a courtroom, family kitchen or queue at a train station distributes roles, permitted replies and forms of correction.
Set a local assignment without turning Melbourne or Sydney into mere backdrops. Ask students to record with consent, or recollect, an exchange on a tram, in a queue for coffee, or in a letter from a former friend. Transform it into another genre while preserving its social pressure. Advice becomes accusation; agreement becomes a performance of politeness. Revision shows that meaning is not sealed inside an utterance.
Grammar as a Writer’s Constraint
For Wittgenstein, grammar does not mean school grammar. It describes conditions that make a use intelligible, including criteria for calling something correct or wrong. Distinguish descriptive observation from the pressure to legislate. A student may ask whether a character’s phrase is odd, but the philosophical question is what shared practice would count as evidence that it is appropriate.
Creative exercises expose this distinction. Draft a page in which a character follows an explicit rule, then revise so the rule breaks or bends. Alternatively, students invent a private signal and imagine what would count as understanding it by another person. These tasks connect to rule-following and private language without reducing literary work to an illustration of an argument.
A Workshop Sequence for the Semester
A compact sequence keeps interpretation and invention in motion. Each session moves from a precise textual encounter to a bounded draft and then to conversation about what changed.
- Open with a language-use diagnostic in which students collect and transform ambiguous utterances from daily life.
- Match each key passage with a micro-scene that activates the same social practice in a different genre.
- Map language-games by naming participants, shared expectations, possible replies and the work each utterance performs.
- Keep philosophical briefings brief, using them to frame the writing problem rather than settle every interpretive dispute.
- Revise in pairs, with reviewers asked to describe effects before proposing changes or declaring an intention.
- Collect selected drafts and commentaries in a portfolio that documents experimentation, feedback and changing choices.
Assessment of the sequence should reward responsiveness and precision, not conformity to a preferred reading. A student who misstates a doctrine but produces a perceptive account of how a scene changes its language may demonstrate stronger understanding than one who reproduces a textbook definition.
Assessment, Copyright and Classroom Care
Creative assessment can include a finished sequence, annotated notebook and reflective commentary on revision. Set criteria around formal control, responsiveness to context, awareness of convention and clarity about choices. Do not grade students on philosophical orthodoxy. Oral presentations and recorded listening exercises can add value, but they require alternatives for students who cannot or prefer not to speak publicly.
Legal and ethical habits belong in the design rather than a final warning. The Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) applies to copying and communicating protected material; short quotations, institutional licences and Creative Commons permissions have different conditions, so record the source and permission basis for every public excerpt. Accessible design should meet the Disability Standards for Education 2005, providing captioned, transcript and downloadable formats where media are assigned. Policies on academic integrity and generative AI vary, so state the relevant rules plainly.
From Course Work to Public Writing
The final project can leave the seminar room without diluting its philosophical discipline. Students might write for a campus magazine, community zine, literary journal such as Overland or The Lifted Brow, or an audio project shared with a partner school. Public readers need not know the philosophical terms, but they can test whether the language creates effects its maker understands. Editors and peers then ask whether the work communicates while preserving ambiguity rather than disguising it.
Begin the next unit by selecting one short passage from Philosophical Investigations and writing a companion scene that changes its social setting. Bring the passage, scene and a note on the language-game each performs to the first workshop. Reading, imitating, altering and reflecting make ordinary language philosophy an ongoing practice of writing.