Teaching Cavell’s Pursuits of Happiness in Film and Philosophy
Teaching Cavell’s Pursuits of Happiness in a course on film and philosophy asks students to examine a philosophical problem through cinema’s forms. The book moves between literature, argument and film, taking familiar judgements about success into difficult territory: the moral knowledge required to pursue happiness.
Cavell’s pursuit is not a promise of a cure for unhappiness. His attention falls on ordinary language, self-knowledge and what our commitments reveal about ourselves and others. A film seminar can test philosophical claims, provided students distinguish philosophy from the search for a reassuring message.
That work suits Australia’s compact semesters, strong tutorial traditions and rich public film institutions. Close viewing and ordinary language analysis connect philosophical stakes to films without reducing either to illustration or personal reaction.
Happiness and moral perfectionism
Begin with the difference between happiness as a private feeling and happiness as a contested public ideal. Cavell asks how our words about a fulfilled life expose the moral standards we claim to share. Reading a passage alongside a scene makes this concrete: whose suffering counts as evidence, and what does a character owe after hearing another person’s appeal? His concern with acknowledgment makes the relation between one person’s claim and another’s need philosophically decisive.
His concern with moral perfectionism keeps the topic from becoming advice about positive thinking. Pursuing happiness involves doing one’s best, but the demand is not for a flawless person or an attainable state of contentment. Ask students to formulate a claim, then identify the counterexample that prevents it becoming a slogan.
Film as philosophical argument
Place film and philosophy in dialogue rather than treating one as an example of the other. Before screening, students write two ordinary sentences about a character’s prospects: “He has what it takes” and “She should give it a go.” After viewing, they revise them through framing, sound, editing and omissions, exercising Cavell’s interest in the ordinary as a site of philosophical difficulty.
A weekly rhythm can combine a short reading, a full sequence or feature, and a seminar in which one student presents a scene closely while another links it to an argument. Keep interpretation with a specific moment. Australian tutorial discussions are useful here, but students should distinguish a claim about the film from a claim about life in general.
The film that is not Cavell’s book
The Pursuit of Happyness, directed by Gabriele Muccino, is tempting because its title appears to echo Cavell’s book. Make the difference explicit. The film follows a father and son facing homelessness and insecure work; Cavell’s essays examine the ethical and linguistic structure of pursuing happiness. Neither interprets the other, and conflating the titles would erase the difficulty before it begins.
Use the discrepancy productively. Does the film equate persistence with moral virtue? How does it represent failure when failure threatens someone else’s security? The opening pursuit of a toy, the unpaid internship and the ticket-sales episode can be discussed as cinematic decisions rather than proof that “hardship builds character.” Notice also what the film leaves unresolved.
Ordinary language and the first person
Ordinary language philosophy supplies a method for examining expressions students already use. Instead of treating philosophical questions as technical problems detached from daily life, ask what speakers are doing when they describe someone as successful, admirable, lucky or responsible. These expressions conceal evaluative judgements that may require defence, and close reading of Cavell’s prose trains attention on that hidden work.
That work connects to the first person. The article on the grammar of I provides a Wittgensteinian parallel for asking how “I” functions in self-description. Students can test whether “self-made man” is an empirical boast, a moral demand or a story sustained through hardship. The questions remain attached to the film’s voice and narration.
Embodiment, emotion and ethical stakes
Make embodied difference part of the analysis. Attention to faces, pauses, movement and voice reveals forms of recognition that dialogue conceals. If students are asked only to recover a lesson or thesis, they may miss how a shot establishes dignity, or how a soundtrack solicits sympathy while withholding another perspective. Film becomes philosophical when its form is treated as part of the argument.
Discuss identification without demanding one correct emotional response. Students can note where sympathy is solicited, where it is refused and where a minor gesture outweighs speech. The Australian “fair go” provides a familiar ideal to test through merit, luck, structural disadvantage and the limits of individual effort.
Building the course in Australia
Australian film culture offers settings beyond the lecture theatre. Melbourne’s ACMI and the National Film and Sound Archive in Canberra provide places where questions about cinema can be encountered through exhibitions and discussion, while Sydney’s festivals and arthouse cinemas support screenings understood as cultural events. A class visit becomes especially productive when students prepare a short curator-style commentary beforehand.
A typical subject may run for ten or twelve teaching weeks, combining a two-hour seminar with independent study. Use it deliberately: one week for Cavell’s vocabulary, one for narrative and ethics, one for autobiographical speech, and one for a student-led comparison. Moodle can organise readings, while AustLit, often available through institutional credentials, supports Australian representations of aspiration and disadvantage. In the Australian scholarly market, library holdings determine which texts students can consult without personal subscriptions.
Keep the resource mix modest and transparent. Texts can circulate through the university library, and filmed scenes can be shown under appropriate classroom permissions after checking Australian classification requirements. The purpose is not to imitate a commercial masterclass, but to give students sustained access to a demanding book while showing why philosophical writing matters for how they watch.
Assessment that rewards argument
Assessment should reward an argued relationship between philosophy and cinematic evidence. A short essay might trace one claim from Pursuits of Happiness through two scenes, distinguishing textual support from an interesting comparison with another film. A seminar presentation can test whether a student moves from a precise moment to a philosophical question, then acknowledges an objection that remains unresolved.
Feedback should address more than interpretation. Mark whether students identify evaluative language, attend to film form and qualify their claims. Peer review can use small tutorial groups to discuss a provisional argument, each student responsible for one objection. A brief reflective note on changed understanding adds little workload but documents philosophical learning.
Try this semester by beginning with one short scene, one ordinary phrase and one unresolved question. Share a lesson sequence or teaching reflection with OLP & Literary Studies Online, where Cavell’s work can meet other resources on ordinary language philosophy. Let close attention reopen settled answers, and keep the pursuit genuinely shared.