Cavell, Moral Perfectionism, And The Bildungsroman
Stanley Cavell’s writing on moral perfectionism offers a distinctive way to read the Bildungsroman, the novel of formation in which a character’s education unfolds through error, disappointment, conversation, and renewed self-understanding. For Cavell, moral development is rarely a matter of applying a fixed rule. It involves learning how to acknowledge others and finding a voice capable of answering to one’s own experience.
This approach connects literary interpretation with ordinary language philosophy. Novels become sites where ethical concepts are tested in lived situations: family conflict, friendship, love, shame, work, and social exclusion. Cavell’s discussions of Shakespeare, Emerson, Thoreau, Austen, and film can therefore illuminate both canonical and contemporary narratives of growing up, including those shaped by Australian institutions and landscapes.
Formation As A Change In Voice
The Bildungsroman is often described as a story of maturation, but “maturity” can sound too smooth and predictable. Cavell’s moral perfectionism gives the genre a more demanding vocabulary. A person changes by recognising that their present way of speaking and acting has become inadequate, then attempting to make themselves intelligible again.
This transformation is ethical because it concerns relations with others. The protagonist must learn to hear rebuke, express desire, admit dependence, and distinguish genuine conviction from borrowed opinion. Development is therefore a change in voice: the character becomes responsible for what they say without imagining that self-knowledge can ever be complete.
Emersonian Perfectionism And The Ordinary
Cavell draws on Ralph Waldo Emerson’s idea that the self is called towards a further self, a better possibility that cannot be reduced to a final ideal. Moral perfectionism names this continuing movement. It is not perfectionism in the sense of flawless performance, moral purity, or competitive achievement.
The ordinary is central to this movement. A gesture at the dinner table, an evasive answer, a conversation between friends, or the refusal to apologise can reveal the ethical shape of a life. Literary realism is especially suited to such moments because it shows how moral change emerges within familiar practices rather than extraordinary acts of heroism.
The Bildungsroman Beyond Progress
Traditional accounts of the Bildungsroman often treat the protagonist’s education as a gradual integration into society. Cavell complicates that pattern. Becoming educated may require resisting the social world’s available roles, particularly when those roles demand silence, conformity, or emotional dishonesty.
The resulting narrative may end without a settled identity. Its achievement lies in a renewed capacity for conversation and acknowledgment. A protagonist can remain uncertain about work, love, class, gender, or belonging while becoming more responsive to the claims of others. This open-endedness helps explain why the genre remains relevant in contemporary fiction.
Acknowledgment And Moral Knowledge
Cavell distinguishes acknowledgment from knowledge. We may know facts about another person while refusing to acknowledge their suffering, authority, or separateness. In a novel, this distinction appears through scenes of avoidance: a character sees what has happened but cannot yet respond to it as something that demands action.
Moral perfectionist reading attends to these failures without reducing them to psychological defects. The question is not simply whether a protagonist possesses good principles. It is whether the character can recognise another person’s reality and accept the costs of responding. Such scenes often provide the deepest education in the novel.
Gender, Authority, And Self-Reliance
Cavell’s engagement with women’s writing, particularly Jane Austen and George Eliot, shows how moral perfectionism intersects with gendered forms of authority. A heroine’s education may involve learning to trust her judgement while refusing the fantasy of total independence. Self-reliance becomes a practice of accountable speech rather than solitary self-assertion.
This perspective is useful for reading novels in which domestic arrangements, professional expectations, or romantic conventions restrict a character’s agency. It also opens questions about whose development counts as socially legible. Aboriginal, migrant, queer, and working-class Bildungsromane may expose the narrowness of models based on individual advancement within established institutions.
Australian Contexts Of Becoming
Australian readers can place these questions beside the country’s distinctive educational and social geography. A novel set between a regional town and a university in Melbourne or Sydney may portray development through movement across class, accent, and institutional cultures. The character’s “coming of age” can involve learning when to say “mate”, when formal language is expected, and how belonging is negotiated rather than granted.
The Australian literary market also complicates the genre’s usual trajectory. Small independent presses, university reading groups, and writers’ festivals in places such as Adelaide, Brisbane, and Hobart often support intimate novels that do not fit a simple success narrative. Regional campuses and long-distance study add further dimensions: education may be experienced through online seminars, casual employment, family obligations, and the pressure to leave home without fully leaving it behind.
Reading Cavell In The University
Cavell’s method encourages close reading rather than the extraction of a single moral lesson. Students can examine changes in tone, interruptions, repeated phrases, scenes of confession, and moments when a character withdraws from conversation. These formal details show how a novel represents ethical learning through its language and structure.
In an Australian tutorial, discussion might move from Austen or Dickens to a recent novel by an Australian writer, asking what counts as progress in each setting. The comparison need not force local fiction into an imported philosophical framework. Instead, Cavell’s concepts can become occasions for testing how moral education is imagined across different histories, communities, and forms of speech.
For readers pursuing these questions, OLP & Literary Studies Online offers a scholarly space for following work on Cavell, Wittgenstein, ordinary language philosophy, and literary studies. Researchers and students can also share responses, reading discoveries, or relevant events through the OLP guestbook, helping sustain the conversations that moral perfectionism places at the centre of intellectual life.